a network of funders promoting increased and more effective funding in Africa through building and sharing knowledge
23 Apr
Imagine an African government with a desire to encourage connection, transparency and collaboration among their donors. Imagine a group of foundations who have chosen not to operate in silos, but instead to share their work, find synergies and combine their resources for wide and sustainable impact.
Such an office exists within the Government of Liberia. It is a pilot project based within the Office of the President and financially supported by private dollars, that embraces reporting and the tracking of outcomes. A tracking system available for the world to see (via the web), provides an avenue of accountability by the country’s citizens and the world at large.
During the recent AGAG retreat my colleagues questioned, fairly, the issues of sustainability, and whether or not being housed within the government will dampen the integrity of the project. I could be proven wrong, but because there are many players involved — not just those from private foundations– it reduces the likelihood. The office has connected with nonprofits working on the ground, individual donors, and other leaders within civil society. Instead of remaining anonymous, the funders of the project have created a grassroots movement to get others donors involved; to let the world know about the project with the hope it might be a replicable model.
For those of you questioning the accountability of the Liberia leadership, be reminded we are all accountable. You can’t simply question whether or not someone is accountable; you must also be willing to step up if you find that they are not. That responsibility now belongs to you as well.
Regarding sustainability, honestly, only time will tell. But the leadership within the government and those foundations involved are committed to nurturing the project over the remaining two years. Not just through funding, but also by helping develop relationships, systems, and when appropriate, stepping away (often difficult for us) to let the leadership lead.
And for those of you who continually question the authenticity of African leaders – choosing to lump all into the same proverbial barrel - chances are you have plenty of corruption to deal with on your own soil. Let this leadership be free to choose a path of integrity and innovation for their people.
Yvonne Moore is the Executive Director of the Daphne Foundation, a family foundation focused on the causes and consequence of poverty in New York City and in Western Africa. Her foundation is part of a three-year pilot project, The Philanthropy Secretariat, based within the Government of Liberia. The focus of the Secretariat is to connect foundations investing in the country’s re-development to help increase impact, sustainability and improve their connections to and between other foundations, government and civil society.
2 Responses for "Guest Blog - Encouraging Transparency in Philanthropy"
I love the tone of this entry - hopeful but firm - and am in absolute agreement with the final statement. Its so much easier to judge and dismiss rather than dig in and help allow for change. Thanks for your words.
Yvonne could have added that too often in the past it has been western multi-nationals (and some intelligence agencies) who helped provide the serious grease for the pump of corruption in West Africa. In countries like Liberia and Sierra Leone, decades of violent civil war and unrest have meant that the nascent institutions of a renewed civil society are only beginning to take hold. So where does that leave those of us who care so much about the future of the continent with dollars to give? Government or large NGOs who do great work but aren’t always accountable when it comes to issues of long-term sustainability that Yvonne rightly points out must be dealt with more seriously lest we perpetuate continued dependence on outsiders on the continent. Like Yvonne says, maybe this effort will prove fool hearty and corruption of a system will engulf even the best intentioned African leaders. Again, what’s the alternative? More dependence on well-intentioned or otherwise Western NGOs? It’s time to try new things and kudos to Yvonne and her colleagues for taking this risk. Hugh Hogan
Leave a reply